How are defendants of high-profile court cases framed in the media? A qualitative analysis of news media coverage of Caroline Flack’s arrest
![Thumbnail](/bitstream/handle/10026.1/18515/TPSS-Vol14n2_548-570Matthews.pdf.jpg?sequence=6&isAllowed=y)
Date
2021Author
Subject
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
This present study aims to investigate whether news media coverage on Caroline Flack’s arrest, in December 2019, showed characteristics of ‘Trial by Media’ (TBM) through identification of one-sided, unbalanced or predominantly negative, sensationalised or speculative news coverage. Caroline Flack’s case has importance due to her ‘media trial’ potentially contributing to her mental health issues, and subsequent suicide two months after her arrest. This study also aims to assess how much this media coverage could have contributed to this. Forty news media articles were analysed from the 18-day period, starting from her arrest, using Media Framing Analysis (MFA; Giles & Shaw, 2009). MFA is a five-step analytic process that identifies the story, analyses the characters, narrative form, language (thematic analysis) and links to wider social context. The results of this study provide evidence to support Caroline being subjected to TBM, showing characteristics of sensationalisation of the crime, use of ‘evidence’ that would be inadmissible in court, negative portrayals of her character, one-sided (Vitelli, 2018) and speculative reporting (Greer & McLaughlin, 2012). This study also concluded that media coverage did contribute to her mental health issues, however there was much evidence in the data that suggested she had a history of mental health and that the Criminal Prosecution Service (CPS), media and public ignored this evidence. Links to the wider social context also suggested other potential contributors, such as her involvement with realty TV.
Citation
Matthews, L. (2021) 'How Are Defendants of High-Profile Court Cases Framed in the Media? A Qualitative Analysis of News Media Coverage of Caroline Flack’s Arrest', The Plymouth Student Scientist, 14(2), pp. 548-570.
Publisher
Journal
Volume
Issue
Recommended, similar items
The following license files are associated with this item:
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Moving image production and the pedagogical development of media literacy
Parker, Kayla; French, L; Moore, S (Cambridge Scholars PublishingNewcastle upon Tyne, 2012-04)This chapter states the case for the pedagogical value of moving image production in the development of media literacy. In the context of this chapter, the concept of media literacy is extended to encompass not just the ... -
Message Journal, Issue 5: COVID-19 SPECIAL ISSUE Capturing visual insights, thoughts and reflections on 2020/21 and beyond...
Multiple authors; Abdisalam, Sadia; Alexander, James; Evans, Carole; Ayling, Tom; Barness, Jessica; Bîrhală, Diana; Borțoi, Maria; Canniffe, Bernard J.; Capaldi, Patti; Cardoso, Tânia A.; Class Action Collective; Culliford, Megan; Cunningham, Stephanie; Davies, Meg; Dey, Subir; Frame, Matthew; Ganci, Aaron; Gibbons, Peter; Gvozdeva, Sofija; Herrmann, Elizabeth; Lee, Chae Ho; Hoffmann, Alma; Kamaruzzaman, Hedzlynn; Karp, Merle; Kaufman-Hill, Holly K.; Kilburn, John; Korenblat, Joshua; Lehrer, Warren; Lewis, Erica V. P.; Lhowe, Christine; Li, Xinyi; Salchow Macarthur, Kelly; Mayers, Shelly; McCarthy, Steven; Milea, Bianca; Nesteruk, Sara; Normoyle, Cat; Teague, Jessica; Nini, Paul; Osborne, Emily; Shefrin, Sima Elizabeth; Shim, Kyuha; Sibrian, Angelica; Sinni, Gianni; Sgarro, Irene; Smart, David; Soar, Matt; Tang, Junie; Tegtmeyer, Rebecca; Thon Knutsen, Ane; Thomas, Isobel; Westley, Darryl; Winstanley, Lisa; Woo, Danne; Wood, Dave; Gregory, Helena; Raeburn, Colin; Malcolm, Jackie (University of Plymouth, 2022-02)If there is a theme running through the Message Covid-19 special issue, it is one of caring. Of our own and others’ resilience and wellbeing, of friendship and community, of students, practitioners and their futures, of ... -
The Demise of the Traditional Jury and Jury Impartiality with Particular Focus on Media Intrusion
Clarke, Jessica (University of Plymouth, 2018)In a world where 24 hour news and social media are ingrained into people’s everyday lives it can be difficult to uphold traditional values and practice. This is particularly pertinent in respect of the impact of such ...